Cinnamon Bread

Today I decided to try my hand at baking bread.  I’ve never used yeast before, but my husband’s eyes lit up when I showed him the recipe so I knew I had to give it a try.

This is definitely something that you need to have the whole day for.  It takes about 45 minutes to make the dough, then it needs to rest for two hours.  Then it takes about 10 minutes to roll out, and then again needs to rest for 2 hours.  I started around 9:30am and finished around 4pm.

This recipe is from The Pioneer Woman:

Her pictures are way more beautiful and her bread has many more swirls, so check out her site!

First, melt the butter into whole milk...

Mix 2 room temp eggs with 1/3 cup flour. I added a splash (.5-1 tsp) of vanilla

You'll need two packets of yeast to get 2.5 tsps, I just dumped them into a bowl and measured from that

Mix 3.5 cups flour with 1 tsp salt, I used Kosher.

About the vanilla- this stuff is top notch. Look for it on cooking shows- no one is using McCormick anymore, they all use this.

The melted butter and milk need to cool down to 120-130 degrees. Do you like my high tech cooling method?

The yeast gets added to the milk/butter. Please don't kill my yeast!

And now we wait for 10 minutes.

Meanwhile, look at my poor phone. This is what I use to read the recipe online. I need an iPad!

Ok, time to pour the butter/milk/yeast into the sugar and eggs. This was left in my NONSTICK pan. What IS this stuff?

Slowly add the flour, scrape down the sides as needed. Switch to the dough hook, and beat on medium speed for 10 minutes.

During this time my mixer was literally walking around my counter.  I had to stand there the whole time with the baby in one arm, the other holding down the mixer, and the eyes in the back of my head watching the toddler.  Oy.  The dough makes a funny butt-slapping sound as it hits the sides of the bowl.  If it sounds like you are in a low-budget adult film, you are doing it right.

The dough can goop up on the sides. This is ok!

My God, I did it. I made dough!

Warm up a glass or metal bowl and drizzle in some oil. The stove element is NOT on.

Our adorable dough now needs to rest for 2 hours.

It rose!!!

I'm so excited!

Mix up some cinnamon and sugar!

Roll out the dough and cover with butter, cinnamon and sugar

I think countertops are disgusting because they can’t be washed.  Sure you can lysol them, but then you have to eat lysol.  So I don’t put any food directly on them… yes… OCD…

Make sure your pan is nice and buttered

Let that baby rise for another two hours and into the oven it goes

Ok, here is where things got scary…

It seemed to really be growing in the oven.. is it supposed to do that?

What the hell? Why did the side explode?

Time is up... but it's not that brown. And it's raw inside.

Time for a drink. Crap.

After 8 more minutes at a lower temp, I declare it done.

The crust really couldn't take anymore, so I just hoped the inside would be done.

Cinnamon sugar butter, anyone?

The final product!

So was spending 7 hours on this worth it?  The first bite, I said yes.  The few after… meh.  It’s really, really good.  But it’s a lot of work for something that is going to be high in calories and not really provide a full meal for my family.  When I go back to work full time, will it be worth 50% of my time off?  No.  But seeing as tho I’m on maternity leave, it was a nice project to have for the day.  However, after all that time and effort I’d really prefer to have dinner prepared, not just cinnamon bread.  I’d feel better if it were a savory bread or even just plain white bread that I could use for toast and sandwiches.

If you are looking for a delicious cinnamon bread recipe, then this it it for sure.  Tonight I’m going to use it to make cinnamon toast for dessert, “The Right Way” according to the Pioneer Woman (

Unfortunately, I still have to figure out what’s for dinner.

Overall: 3.25/5

Taste: 5/5 (perfect cinnamon bread!)

Ease: 2/5 (it wasn’t super difficult, it was just tedious and took forever!)

Health: 2/5 (white bread with extra sugar?)

$$$: 4/5 (the only extra thing I had to buy was yeast, and that was less than $.99 for what I used)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s